Indemnity clauses in construction contracts require one party to cover losses or claims for another. It’s essentially a worst-case scenario clause, but it’s a reality that some Florida construction projects face and contracts must address.
However, sometimes, the law imposes this obligation even without a contract. As an indemnitee, ensuring you receive what you’re entitled to can be complex. It’s important to understand how to approach these complex issues and to ensure each party is given the best opportunity to adhere to the law and signed contracts.
Relying on Contract Language
The starting point for any indemnity claim is the contract itself. It should clearly define the scope and limits of indemnity. Your Florida construction contracts should answer most of the questions that arise during matters of indemnity.
For example, the contracts all parties signed should define what events can trigger the indemnity in the first place. Is there a limit on how much can be paid out? Your contract should also make it clear if the indemnity covers first-party losses, third-party claims, or both.
When indemnity is imminent, questions must be answered such as whether there is a duty to defend as well as indemnify and who gets to select defense counsel for the case ahead.
Insurance Coverage for Indemnity Claims
Contracts often include both insurance and indemnity provisions. These can conflict, especially regarding the coverage of losses. In Florida construction contracts, for example, the owner might need to buy property or builder’s risk insurance, while contractors must have liability insurance. These policies often include waivers of subrogation, which can complicate the determination of which insurance applies and the extent of each party’s liability.
When a loss occurs, it’s crucial to determine which insurance policy applies. Courts often place the risk of loss solely on the insurance, barring subrogation claims against other insured parties. However, disputes can arise about the cause of the loss and whether it was due to external forces or contractor negligence. These disputes can lead to complex chains of indemnity claims among contractors, subcontractors, and their insurers.
Tendering a Claim
To protect indemnity rights, indemnitees must understand the requirements for tendering a claim. While most states only require notice, some require a formal tender to trigger an insurer’s duty to defend. Issues can get more complicated depending on the insurance policy terms, such as “other insurance” clauses, deductibles, and policy hierarchies.
Navigating the Legal Issues of Indemnity
Indemnitees should involve their indemnitors early in the defense and settlement discussions. This can prevent the loss of indemnity rights. Contracts can address control over the defense, allowing indemnitees to choose their own counsel. Additionally, when insurers issue a reservation of rights, indemnitees might retain control over the defense.These issues are inherently complex. A proactive approach to involving an experienced Florida construction law attorney in the early stages and contract drafting of any construction project in the Sunshine State is the best way to protect yourself. If you find yourself on either side of an indemnity matter, contact Florida Construction Law Group today.